Monday, September 27, 2010

First Pages

This past weekend I attended the SCBWI-Carolinas annual regional conference. I learned about plot, pacing, and novel outlines and connected with old and new friends. Workshops and general sessions with editors and agents packed the schedule.



Liz Waniewski, Senior Editor at Dial Books for Young Readers

On Saturday we gathered for an hour titled, "First Pages." Conference attendees were invited to submit the first 200 words of their work-in-progress.Thirty annonymous submissions were randomly chosen and read by a panel that included two editors and one agent. After each page was read the experts gave their on-the-spot-opinions on whether or not they would continue to read and their reasons why. This process mimics what they do everyday. Receiving piles of submissions, they are trained to quickly assess if a manuscript conveys conflict, grabs the reader, has voice, and is well-written.

Chris Richman, agent with Upstart Crow Literary Agency


Having participated in "First Pages" before, I have come to appreciate their collective wisdom and often reach the same conclusions these professionals do while I am listening to the submissions. Pictured here were the three experts on Saturday.

Alvina Ling, Senior Editor at Little, Brown Books

Since there were close to 200 attendees, I thought that the chance of mine being read was pretty slim. Without my full attention, I suddenly heard the opening line, "I am a scrubby old corn stalk stuck in the middle of Grandmother's rose garden." I sat up, grabbed the arm of my friend sitting next to me, whispered "that's mine!" and heard the speaker continue:


"If I hadn’t promised Daddy that I’d try and stick it out, I’d be on the first bus back to South Carolina. Wish I could hide under the linen tablecloth hanging to the floor like I used to. But I’m not a kid anymore.


"Ginny scolded me before dinner. 'Katie, you should wash your hair and put on a clean blouse before going downstairs.' But like always, I didn’t mind her advice. Just because she’s three years older than me she thinks she knows everything. Miss Smarty Pants. Almost as bad as Grandmother herself.

"So here I sit in my grandparent’s house in fancy Myers Park, grubby as a cotton picker. It doesn’t matter I’ve been unpacking boxes and trunks all day. Ginny has been too, but somehow she looks fresh and pretty. I notice my broken, dirty fingernails and I shove my hands into my skirt pockets. At least I changed out of my dungarees.

"'Anna Katherine!' Grandmother’s voice is sharp. 'Would you please fold your hands so that Granddaddy can say grace?'"

                                              * * * * * * * * * * *
Two hundred words that I spent hours on. What would the panel say? Would this be enough to grab their interest and make them want to read more? Would my manuscript make it through this first critical reading?
 
I wanted to hear their comments but was scared. The last time my first page was read -- from a previous version and prior to developing this plot line  -- was dismissed as uninteresting. My heart pounded.  Here are some of their comments that I scribbled as they talked:
 
"Strong characterization. Strong sense of main character. Good example of voice. Liked the first line. Liked the information conveyed."
 
Best yet, each member of the panel said they would continue reading.
 
I was ecstatic.
 
It took ten minutes for my heart to stop racing.
 
Now, back to work. I have a book waiting to be written. And three recognized literary professionals who said they'd read more.
 
How about you? Are you hooked?

8 comments:

CL said...

Congratulations, Carol!
I love 'First Pages,' too. I always learn so much!
Mine was not read, but my friends' were, so I got a vicarious thrill-- and they were well-received; now my whole critique group is feeling proud!

Carol Baldwin said...

Thanks, Constance. My critique group all recognized my story too. It is nice to have the support of fellow writers and artists.

elysabeth said...

cool - so now you have some direction and all those first page sessions have finally paid off. So what are you waiting for? Get the story written already - lol - E :)

Elysabeth Eldering
Author of the Junior Geography Detective Squad, 50-state, mystery, trivia series

Where will the adventure take you next?

http://jgdsseries.blogspot.com
http://jgdsseries.weebly.com

Joyce Moyer Hostetter said...

I'd keep reading! Great job! And congrats on the positive responses to your first page.

Scary stuff!

Gretchen said...

So that was yours! I loved it. This First Pages session was exactly what I needed to hear.

Carol Baldwin said...

Thanks Gretchen, Joyce, & Elysabeth. First Pages has taught me a lot (as in that other version got totally trashed!!) and today I was in my writing chair working on the next chapter. But of course, now (according to Liz) I have to add a romance and then (according to Steve Watkins) kill someone off...so the plot thickens!

Jean said...

How painfully exciting! We do love the ecstatic stress of this job, I think!

Blessings,
Jean Hall

Amy Tate said...

Yes, most definitely! I felt your MC's emotion - I even looked at my own fingernails, lol! That must have been thrilling to hear them speak about your work. Congrats!